The Great Debate: Ohio’s Best BBQ / Pizza / Seafood Spots Ranked
In Cincinnati, just a short drive west from downtown, the neighborhood of Over-the-Rhine offers a vibrant dive into Ohio’s barbecue scene. At Eli’s BBQ, smoked meats take center stage with a pitmaster’s passion that honors traditional Central Texas techniques, but with a local twist. The smoky aroma fills the air as you sample their brisket, tender and rich, paired with house-made sauces that vary from sweet to spicy. Over-the-Rhine’s historic brick-lined streets and revitalized warehouses provide a perfect backdrop for savoring slow-cooked meats. Visiting in the cooler months enhances the experience, when the warmth of the smokehouse complements the crisp Ohio air.
Heading northeast toward Cleveland, the city is a treasure trove for pizza aficionados, especially in the Tremont neighborhood, known for its eclectic eateries and artsy vibe. Angelo’s Pizza stands out here, crafting thin-crust pies that draw inspiration from the Italian immigrants who shaped the area. The signature pies often feature a balance of fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and an assortment of locally sourced toppings, baked in a brick oven to achieve a perfect char and crunch. Tremont’s lively streets are bustling on weekend evenings, making it an ideal time to join locals for a slice and soak in the neighborhood’s warm, communal spirit.
Further south, in Columbus, the Short North Arts District is a hotspot for diverse culinary experiences, including some of the best seafood offerings in the state. The Pearl, a restaurant that embraces Ohio’s proximity to the Great Lakes, offers fresh fish like Lake Erie perch and walleye prepared with a nod to both classic and contemporary techniques. The atmosphere here blends urban chic with comfortable elegance, making it a favorite for both casual diners and special occasions. Visiting in late spring or summer, when the outdoor patio is open, enhances the connection to the region’s natural bounty and vibrant energy.
Travel northwest from Toledo, about a half-hour drive, to the Maumee Bay area along Lake Erie, where seafood lovers can enjoy the freshest catches at the Maumee Bay State Park’s nearby eateries. This lakeside park, known for its scenic wetlands and birdwatching opportunities, also serves as a gateway to tasting local freshwater fish. The nearby town of Oregon features restaurants specializing in perch and walleye, often grilled or fried, embodying the lake’s rich fishing heritage. Early fall is an excellent time to visit, as the weather is still mild and the park’s natural beauty is at its peak with colorful foliage.
In the heart of Dayton, the Oregon District offers a unique twist on pizza that reflects the city’s Midwestern charm and creativity. Dewey’s Pizza, a local favorite here, prides itself on inventive toppings and a crust that strikes a perfect balance between chewy and crispy. The neighborhood itself, known for its historic buildings and lively arts scene, creates a perfect setting to enjoy a casual evening out. Weekends bring a vibrant crowd and sometimes live music, adding to the experience of savoring a hand-crafted pie in this cultural hub.
To experience a distinctly Ohio barbecue style, venture to Cleveland’s West Side Market, an indoor public market renowned for its diverse food stalls and local vendors. Among the offerings, Sokolowski’s University Inn stands as a Cleveland institution with a history dating back to 1923. Their barbecue ribs and pulled pork carry a legacy of Eastern European flair blended with American smoking traditions, served in a casual, bustling environment. Visiting midweek allows for a more relaxed market stroll, where you can sample various regional specialties alongside barbecue favorites.
Lastly, the town of Sandusky, just north of Cleveland on the shores of Lake Erie, provides a seafood experience that reflects the seasonal rhythms of the lake. Fishers Landing, a local eatery near the waterfront, serves up fresh Lake Erie walleye and perch, often prepared simply to highlight the natural flavors. The nearby Sandusky Bay Pathway offers scenic hiking trails and birdwatching, making it a great day trip combining outdoor exploration with a rewarding seafood meal. Summer, when the lake is calm and the sunsets are stunning, is the best time to savor this lakeside culinary gem.